Severed Finger Halloween Dog Treat Recipe

Are you looking for a spooky and healthy Halloween dog treat recipe? This severed finger dog treat combines healthy ingredients like pumpkin and applesauce to deliver delicious Fall flavors to your dog. Plus, the severed finger shape will delight pet parents!

The recipe for these treats is super simple and one that you can use to stamp out treats with a cookie-cutter, too. I chose this recipe for the severed finger treats because it’s a soft treat instead of a crunchy treat. It’s the perfect consistency to use with a silicone mold!

Spooky Halloween Severed Finger Dog Biscuits

Spooky Severed Finger Dog Treat Recipe

I wouldn’t have made these treats if I didn’t stop into Michael’s this weekend. I stopped in for some other Halloween supplies, but I always fall for their silicone molds. I love to have fun shaped to use for gelatin dog treats, frozen pupsicles or biscuits like these. The severed fingers are sold out online, but you can get a whole skeleton hand which is cool!  I also found a similar severed finger mold on Etsy.

When you shop for silicone molds, make sure they’re oven and freezer safe so you can use them for any kind of dog treat recipe.

Zombie Finger dog treat recipe DIY

Proud Dog Chef Cook Book for Dog Treats

Like I mentioned before, I wanted to find a soft dog treat recipe to make these severed finger Halloween dog treats. I thought a crunchy treat might break when I take them out of the mold. My first place to look for dog treat recipes is the cookbook Proud Dog Chef: Tail-Wagging Good Treat Recipes. It’s so handy to have a hardcopy book of dog treat recipes so I don’t have to always use my phone.

The recipe I used is Pumpkin Apple Pooches. You can find other similar recipes on the Proud Dog Mom YouTube channel. I love this one for gluten free peanut butter dog biscuits. It’s very similar to the one I used for the fingers. Check it out to see how Melissa makes them!

Apple Pumpkin Severed Finger Dog Treats

Here’s how I adapted this recipe from Proud Dog Mom to make this creepy severed finger Halloween dog treat recipe for my dogs! I made these for our October Labrador Meet Up and they were a big hit with the dogs and the pawrents!

Treat Ingredients:

  • 1 red apple (you’ll use the skin for finger nails)
  • 3 cups brown rice flour
  • 1 cup coconut flour
  • 1/2 cup pure pumpkin puree
  • 1/2 cup plain applesauce
  • 1/2 cup water

Halloween Severed Finger Dog Treats

Combine the flours together in a large bowl. Add the pumpkin, applesauce and water. Mix with a spoon until it’s incorporated, then use your hands to knead the dough and work it into a ball.

When the dough is well mixed, set aside. Next, create the fingernail for your silicone mold. I used a red apple and peeled off a strip of the skin. Use a pairing knife to slice it into a rough fingernail shape, using the silicone mold as a reference. Cut 8 apple peel “fingernails” and place in the mold with the skin side down.

Next, get your dough and break off small chunks. Work them between your hands to fold a finger shape and press it into the mold. Be careful that the fingernail stays in the right spot. Add dough until it’s level at the top of the mold.

Bake for 25 minutes. Let cool on a wire rack for 5-10 mins then remove from the mold and let cool for additional time.

You can use the leftover dough to stamp out biscuits with a cookie-cutter. I made a bunch of bones!

Store any leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge for about a week.

The next two photos are from our October Labrador meet up with the Labradors of Pittsburgh! The Halloween treats disappeared SCARY FAST!

Spooky Halloween Dog Treat DIY

Halloween dog treats

More Halloween Dog Treat Recipes

I’ve always loved Halloween and all things pumpkin! Making dog treats this time of year is one of my favorite things to do. I have a bunch of other Halloween dog treat recipes for you to make. 

A no-bake recipe gives me a fun project to work on and something to look forward to as the days get shorter closer to Halloween. I was curious about gelatin dog treats for a while and finally got the ingredients I need to make this pumpkin gummy dog treat recipe last year. Since then, I make gelatin treats at least once a month.

Before I got into gelatin treats, I came up with several creative ways to treat the dogs with pumpkin! In this blog post, learn how to make 3 pumpkin dog treat recipes from super simple to more advanced. The first two are frozen, which is one of the easiest ways to make homemade treats. You don’t even need to turn on the oven!

how to make 3 pumpkin dog treat recipes

In the Fall, there are lots of other foods in season besides pumpkin. Try making these Apple and Kale Frozen Dog Treats for a twist on fall flavors. My dogs love these and they’re so healthy!

Halloween Dog Treat Tips

A lot of Halloween dog treat recipes contain pumpkin. It’s a healthy food full of vitamins for your dog! When you buy canned pumpkin puree for your dog, make sure that it’s all-natural and doesn’t contain any other additives or spices. Do not buy pumpkin pie filling, you want plain 100% pumpkin!

The same advice goes for any other ingredients you buy to make dog treats or supplement your dog’s food. Always buy the purest form of the ingredient that you can. Avoid anything with added sugar, salt, onion, garlic, etc.

And as always, remember that treats should only make up a small portion of your dog’s daily diet. If you have a training session or pawty with more treats than usual, you might want to cut back on your dog’s dinner a little bit.

Did you like this post? Check out this other content:
3 Easy Pumpkin Dog Treat Recipes
The Best Dog Chews for Mental Stimulation
Healthy Kale and Apple Frozen Dog Treat Recipe
Dog Mom Halloween Costume: Snow White and the Evil Witch
Surfer Girl and Shark Halloween Couples Costume for Dog Moms



*This post may contain affiliate links. If you purchase through my links, I may earn a small commission. 


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tori Mistick Labrador Dog Mom Blog

Get To Know Tori

Pack Leader

Tori Mistick is a blogger, podcaster and certified Canine Enrichment Specialist. You might call her a professional dog mom! Tori has a soft spot for senior dogs and loves the color pink. Based in Pittsburgh, PA.


Lucy and Burt Wear Wag Repeat

The Pups

Lead Lab Techs

Lucy + Burt are the chocolate labrador duo in charge of testing toys, recipes and activities.

Get to Know the Dogs


Action for Animals